April 14: John 2:1-11; 3:5-8ff; 7:37-39ff

In the previous note, I discussed the possibility that the water which came out from Jesus side after his death (19:34) was intended by the Gospel writer to symbolize Jesus’ giving of the Spirit. If this line of interpretation is at all correct, then we have a clear connection between Jesus’ death (blood) and the Spirit (water). There is confirmation to be found in both the Bread of Life Discourse of chapter 6 (especially verses 51-58ff), as well as in 1 John 5:6-8. Before proceeding to the discussion of those passages, let us consider again the water/Spirit references in the Gospel, to see what theological association with Jesus’ death may be present there.

John 2:1-11

I begin with the Cana miracle episode in 2:1-11. Even though, in that episode, there is no evidence that the water is symbolic of the Spirit, there are certain parallels with the crucifixion scene that are worth noting. First, we have the fact that the Cana episode marks the beginning of Jesus’ earthly ministry, even as his death marks the end of it. Significantly, Jesus’ mother Mary features in both episodes (2:1-5; 19:25-27), the only references to her in the entire Gospel (cf. also 2:12; 6:42). Beyond this, there is the obvious parallel between water-wine and water-blood. The image of wine to symbolize blood is both natural and traditional; in Old Testament and Jewish tradition, wine (both the drinking and pouring out of it) served as a motif for violence, destruction and judgment (on the wicked)—cf. Psalm 75:8; Prov 4:17; Isa 49:26; 51:21f; Jer 25:15; 51:7; Joel 3:13; Rev 14:10, 17-20; 16:19, etc. And, of course, there is the eucharistic symbolism of wine (and the drinking of it) with Jesus’ blood (i.e., his violent death)—cf. 6:51-58; Mark 14:23-25 par, etc.

John 3:5-8ff

Next, we have the water-Spirit connection in the Nicodemus Discourse of chapter 3 (vv. 5-8, cf. the recent article in the series “Spiritualism and the New Testament”). As I have discussed, I view the water-Spirit juxtaposition in these verses as contrastive, reflecting the Johannine dualism that runs through the entire Gospel. That is to say, the contrast is between the ordinary/natural human birth out of physical “water” (in the mother’s womb, etc) and birth out of the “living water” of the Spirit.

As the Discourse proceeds, the concept of new life (birth) out of the Spirit develops into the idea of believers receiving “eternal life” through trust in Jesus (vv. 15-16ff). The specific verb used is e&xw (“hold”), and it occurs frequently in this very context throughout the Gospel (3:36; 5:24-26, 39-40; 6:40, 47, 53-54, etc). Believers “hold” this life within them, a concept that is best understood, in the Johanine theological idiom, in terms of the presence of the Spirit. The expression translated “eternal life” literally means “life of the age[s],” or “life of the age [to come]”, the latter properly capturing the eschatological sense. However, in the Gospel of John, the expression also refers, fundamentally, to the Divine character and nature of the life. That is to say, it signifies the life which God Himself possesses, and which God (the Father) gives to the Son (Jesus); the Son, in turn, gives this same life to believers—see esp. 3:34-35 and 6:57.

In speaking of trust in Jesus, as the Son sent by the Father (vv. 16, 34-35), it is clear that, from the context of vv. 13-15, special emphasis is given to the death of Jesus. The image of “lifting [up] high” (vb u(yo/w) the Son, utilizing the Moses-tradition of the ‘bronze serpent’ (Num 21:9), is an allusion to Jesus’ death (by crucifixion) as he is ‘lifted up’ onto the wooden pole/stake; this is clear from the parallel in 12:32 (with the author’s explanatory comment in v. 33). The Gospel of John is unique in the way that Jesus’ death is included as part of his exaltation/glorification—a dynamic that is not limited to his resurrection and ascension.

There is no clear association with Jesus’ death in the “living water” references of the Samaritan Woman Discourse (4:10-15ff, cf. by earlier discussion on this passage); however, there is such a contextual connection for the parallel in 7:37-39, and this requires some comment.

John 7:37-39

Verses 37-39 lie at the heart of the Discourse-complex of chapters 7-8, which, according to the narrative, took place when Jesus was in Jerusalem for the festival of Sukkot (Booths). A number of commentators (e.g., Brown, pp. 326-9) have referenced the significance of water-imagery as a traditional motif associated with Sukkot, and it is quite likely that Jesus was intentionally drawing upon this in his declaration. The Gospel writer, commenting upon Jesus’ words in v. 39, clearly identifies the “living water” that Jesus gives (par 4:10-15) with the Spirit.

In the chapter 7-8 discourses, there are a number of allusions to Jesus’ death. Most notably, we have the frequent references to the desire of many people (esp. the religious leaders) to see Jesus arrested and/or killed (7:25, 30, 32, 44-45ff; 8:20, 59). Second, Jesus twice (7:33ff; 8:21ff) refers to his “going away” (vb u(pa/gw). This idea of his departure, to be developed extensively in the Last Discourse, has a dual-meaning. On the one hand, there is an allusion to his death, but it is also a reference to his departure back to the Father (in heaven). These two aspects of meaning cannot be separated; however, it is the latter that is primarily in view, especially in section 8:21-30 of the Discourse.

There are a number of important parallels in this section with the exposition in 3:11-21 (of the Nicodemus discourse). Two thematic motifs, in particular, should be noted. First, there is the contrast between “above” (a&nw) and “below” (ka/tw), with the implicit (self-)identification of Jesus as the Son who has come from the Father in heaven (“above”)—vv. 23-24, and note the important exchange that follows in 25-27. On this, cf. the parallel in 3:12-13 (repeated in v. 31ff), along with the use of the adverb a&nwqen (“from above”) in vv. 3, 6.

Second, we have the idea of “lifting (up) high” (vb u(yo/w) the Son of Man (v. 28f), just as earlier in 3:14. As previously noted (cf. above), the Gospel writer understood this aspect of Jesus’ exaltation/glorification primarily in terms of his death on the cross (12:32-33). The implication in v. 29 is that, even at the moment of his death, the Son (Jesus) is united by the bond of filial relationship with the Father; indeed, his death marks an important stage in the Father giving honor to (i.e. exalting) the Son. As in the Gospel of Luke, the Johannine Passion narrative records no ‘cry of dereliction’ by Jesus on the cross (cf. the prior note). The Father remains with him, even in his death.

In the next daily note, we will turn to the Bread of Life Discourse in chapter 6—specifically the eucharistic language of vv. 51-58, in connection with the statement in v. 63—in order to gain a better sense of the relationship between Jesus’ death and the Spirit in Johannine theology.

References above marked “Brown” are to Raymond E. Brown, S.S., The Gospel According to John I-XII, Anchor Bible [AB] vol. 29 (1966).

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *