The Saturday Series feature on this site has been repurposed as Studies on the Spirit—exegetical and theological studies on the (Holy) Spirit, focusing on key passages and developments within the New Testament and (early) Christian tradition. The purpose of the original Saturday Series was to introduce the principles and methods of Biblical Criticism, demonstrating them inductively through studies on selected Scripture passages. This will continue to be an important and integral component of the site; already you can find many examples, including all the earlier studies of the Saturday Series. However, I felt it equally important to introduce this new focus on the Spirit, as a sound understanding of the nature and role of the Holy Spirit, particularly as described in the writings of the New Testament, is vital for believers in Christ today, since there seems to be such a fundamental lack of clear awareness and understanding of the subject within much of modern Christianity.
The Spirit and the Death/Resurrection of Jesus
The first series of studies will examine the role of the Spirit in relation to the death and resurrection of Jesus. This theme is, of course, fitting for the seasonal celebrations of Lent, Holy Week, Easter (Resurrection Sunday), and Pentecost this Spring. It is somewhat surprising that the New Testament Scriptures actually say relatively little (at least, explicitly so) regarding this relationship. Most obvious, perhaps, is the salvation-historical context, in terms of the sequence: how the coming of the Spirit naturally follows the death and resurrection of Jesus, with the implication that the former cannot occur until the latter takes place.
Much more can be said about the role of the Spirit—and, indeed, even the nature of the Spirit—in relation to the death and resurrection of Jesus, based on the evidence attested by the New Testament Scriptures. However, this requires a careful and detailed examination of all the key passages and lines of tradition that touch upon this subject.
Study 1: The Baptism of Jesus in the Gospel Tradition
I choose to begin with the early Gospel Tradition—and, in particular, the role of the Holy Spirit in the tradition of Jesus’ Baptism. In the core Synoptic Tradition, as represented primarily by the Gospel of Mark, this scene of Jesus’ Baptism (Mk 1:9-11 par) represents the first (and arguably the most noteworthy) reference to the Spirit, prefaced immediately by the saying of the Baptist in v. 8 (par): “I dunked [i.e. baptized] you in water, but he will dunk you in (the) holy Spirit [e)n pneu/mati a(gi/w|]”. This saying, which functions in the narrative (and at the level of the historical tradition) as a prophetic statement about the ministry of Jesus, alludes both to Jesus’ Messianic status, and to the coming of the Spirit upon his disciples (believers) following his death and resurrection (Acts 1:5ff). The first thematic aspect (the identification of Jesus as the Messiah) is primary to the Baptism tradition, as will be discussed below.
The Markan Gospel narrates the event as follows:
“And it came to be in those days (that) Yeshua came from Nazaret of the Galîl and was dunked in the Yarden under [i.e. by] Yohanan. And straightaway, (with his) stepping up out of the water, he saw the heavens being split and the Spirit as a dove stepping [i.e. coming] down to him. And there came to be a voice out of the heavens: ‘You are my Son the (be)loved (one), (and) in you I think good [i.e., I think good of you].'” (1:9-11)
This is a core component of the Synoptic Tradition, and the versions of the event in Matthew (3:13, 16-17) and Luke (3:21-22) different in only relatively small ways. Even the Gospel of John (1:32-34) shows awareness of an underlying tradition which generally corresponds to that of the Synoptics. The point will be discussed further in the next study.
What is the significance of the coming of the Spirit down onto/upon (ei)$/e)pi/) Jesus? The saying(s) by the Baptist in Mk 1:7-8 par (cf. also Lk 3:17 par, and the context of vv. 15-16), coupled with the declaration by the Divine/heavenly voice (Mk 1:11 par; cf. 9:7 par), point to the primary significance as being Messianic—that is, the presence of the Spirit identifies Jesus as one specially chosen (i.e., ‘anointed’) by God as His Servant (and “Son”). The Spirit also empowers him toward fulfilling this Messianic role. Within the (Synoptic) Gospel narrative, the Baptism, with the coming of the Spirit upon Jesus, marks the beginning of his public ministry. Moreover, it is to be inferred that the Spirit remained on Jesus (cf. Jn 1:32-33, to be discussed), continuing to empower and guide him, until the moment of his death. Thus, the Spirit’s role throughout the entire Gospel narrative leads up to the critical association with the death (and resurrection) of Jesus. Our examination of this association will develop over the course of the remaining studies.
The Messianic significance of the Spirit at Jesus’ Baptism
In terms of the Baptism tradition, the coming of the Spirit (v. 10) is closely tied to the declaration by the heavenly voice (v. 11)—the two details cannot be separated, and each serves to inform the meaning and significance of the other. The Spirit and the Divine voice both serve to identify Jesus as the Chosen/Anointed One (i.e., Messiah) of God. It is import to realize, in this regard, that the identification of Jesus as God’s Son is fundamentally (and primarily) Messianic.
Within the Synoptic Tradition, Jesus’ identity as the Messiah is rather clearly defined according to two broad lines of Scriptural and Jewish tradition, which may be epitomized as categories of Messianic figure-types: (1) the Prophetic, and (2) the Royal/Davidic. In point of fact, these serve to structure the Synoptic narrative. In the first half of the narrative, the Galilean period, Jesus is identified as a Messianic Prophet, and is only identified as a Royal Messiah (from the line of David) in the second half of the narrative (the Jerusalem period), beginning with the Triumphal Entry (Mk 11:1-10 par), and anticipated by the use of the expression “Son of David” in the prior episode (cf. 10:47-48 par). Only Matthew deviates from this demarcation, introducing the title “Son of David” at several points during the Galilean period (9:27; 12:3, 23; 15:22).
The Infancy narratives (both Matthean and Lukan) focus entirely upon Jesus’ identity as the Royal/Davidic Messiah, and say virtually nothing about his role as a Prophetic Messiah. Yet, these narratives almost certainly represent secondary developments (and additions) to the Synoptic Tradition, and, as such, in their thematic emphases, they reflect the Christological orientation of believers in the mid-late first century, when the idea of Jesus as a Messianic Prophet had lost its importance and had largely vanished from view. In this regard, it is interesting that the Lukan author hews so closely to the Synoptic Tradition, focusing on Jesus almost exclusively as a Messianic Prophet-figure in the Galilean period (cf. the discussion below)—this in spite of his strong emphasis on Jesus as the Royal/Davidic Messiah in the Infancy narrative.
(1) Jesus’ identity as a Messianic Prophet
(cf. Parts 2–3 of the series “Yeshua the Anointed”)
If we consider the coming of the Spirit upon Jesus as a sign of his status as a Messianic (Chosen/Anointed) Prophet, we must look to the background for such an association in the Scriptures, and in subsequent Jewish Tradition. That prophecy was a sign of the presence of the Divine Spirit upon a person is well attested; among the references in the Scriptures, see Num 11:25ff; 24:2; 1 Sam 10:6ff; 2 Sam 23:2; 1 Kings 22:24; 2 Chron 15:1; Isa 59:21; Ezek 2:2, etc.
The early Christian understanding of Jesus as a Messianic Prophet follows three lines of tradition, represented by three distinct Messianic figure-types: (1) Moses, (2) Elijah, and (3) the Anointed herald of Isaiah 61:1ff. Each of these figures is associated with the manifest presence of God’s Spirit, or of a Divinely instilled prophetic Spirit.
For Moses, there are two passages relating to his role as a Divinely-inspired prophet: (i) Numbers 11:10-30 (esp. vv. 24-30), and (ii) Deuteronomy 18:15-22; cf. also the statement in Deut 34:10. The first passage focuses on the presence and activity of the Spirit, while the second came to be the core text for the idea of a Messianic prophet “like Moses” who would appear at the end time. This idea had become well-established in Jewish Tradition by the first century B.C./A.D., and was adopted by early Christians, applying it to Jesus (see esp. Acts 3:22; 7:37). I have discussed the first passage at length in an earlier series on the Holy Spirit in the Old Testament; cf. the notes on Num 11:10-30.
The prophetic spirit that was manifest in the person of Elijah is mentioned in 2 Kings 2:9, 15; in this context, see also the association with the Spirit of YHWH in v. 16, indicating Elijah’s special/chosen status. Traditionally, the miracle-working power of Elijah (and Elisha) is associated with this ‘anointing’ (cf. 1 Kings 19:16) by the Spirit, as in Isa 61:1ff (cf. below). It is this aspect of Jesus’ ministry (i.e., his working of healing miracles, etc) which led to his being identified with the Messianic figure type of Elijah, though elsewhere in the Gospel and early Christian tradition this role is given to John the Baptist (see esp. Lk 1:15, 17, where the prophetic “spirit of Elijah” is closely connected with the presence of the Spirit of God). The idea of Messianic prophet according to the figure-type of Elijah, who would appear at the end-time, largely stems from Malachi 3:23-24 [4:5-6], which expounds the earlier oracle of 3:1ff (cf. my note on “The One Coming” in the series “Yeshua the Anointed”).
Finally, there is the Anointed herald of Isaiah 61:1ff, which is related conceptually to the “Servant of YHWH” figure that recurs throughout the Isaian (and/or deutero-Isaian) oracle-poems. There are actually three key Isaian passages which are fundamental to the idea of a Messianic prophet who is ‘anointed’ by the Spirit of God. I have discussed each of these in the earlier series on “The Old Testament in the Gospel Tradition”, or in the aforementioned series on the Spirit in the Old Testament: (a) 11:1-9 (esp. vv. 1-2 [notes]), (b) 42:1ff (article), and (c) 61:1ff (article). The influence of Isa 11:1-2ff is certain, though the passage is not specifically cited or alluded to in the Gospel Tradition; Jesus is identified as the Spirit-anointed figure of the passage, according to a Messianic interpretation, in 2 Thess 2:8 (citing v. 4). The wording of v. 2 (“The Spirit of YHWH shall rest upon him”) certainly could be seen as having been fulfilled by the coming of the Spirit upon Jesus in the Baptism scene.
More explicit associations, however, are attested for the prophecies of Isa 42:1ff and 61:1ff, both of which are connected with the Baptism scene in the Gospel Tradition (cf. the aforementioned articles). The scene itself almost certainly alludes to Isa 42:1, particularly in the LXX translation, since the word for Hebrew db#u# (“servant”) in Greek is pai=$, which also means “child”. The latter nuance puts the LXX of Isa 42:1 into close alignment with the Gospel Baptism scene, juxtaposing the coming of the Spirit upon Jesus with the declaration that he is God’s Son.
As for Isa 61:1ff, the Lukan Gospel specifically identifies the Baptism of Jesus as the fulfillment of this prophecy. The author does this by moving up the Nazareth scene (cf. Mk 6:1-6 par) to the very beginning of Jesus’ ministry (4:16ff), immediately following the Baptism and Temptation episodes (3:21-22; 4:1-13); Isa 61:1 is famously featured (vv. 18-19ff) in this Lukan version of the Nazareth scene. In context, the coming of the Spirit upon Jesus at the Baptism is to be understood as the ‘anointing’ of the Spirit mentioned in Isa 61:1, a fact that the author more or less confirms by the narrative detail in 4:1, 14. The Spirit, having come down upon Jesus, now guides and empowers him all throughout his ministry; in this regard, Jesus serves as the type-pattern for the mission of the first (apostolic) believers, who continue his Spirit-empowered ministry, as narrated in the book of Acts.
(2) Jesus’ identity as the Royal/Davidic Messiah
(cf. Parts 6, 7, 8 of the series “Yeshua the Anointed”)
If the Divine/heavenly voice of the Baptism scene alludes to Isaiah 42:1 (cf. above), it also evokes the declaration (by YHWH) in Psalm 2:7: “You are my Son”. The original context of this statement of Divine sonship involves the ancient/traditional royal theology, whereby the king was identified—symbolically and ritually—as the “son” of God. For more detail, see my earlier study on Psalm 2, as well as the article in the series “The Birth of the Messiah”. In a variant reading of the Lukan version of the Divine/heavenly declaration (3:22), Psalm 2:7 is more fully (and explicitly) quoted, as from the LXX: “You are my Son; today I have caused you to be (born) [e)gw\ sh/meron gege/nnka/ se]”. This is understandable, given the importance of Ps 2:7 as a Messianic prophecy, both in Jewish Tradition and among early Christians (cf. Acts 13:33; Heb 1:5; 5:5).
The anointing of the king is an obvious motif; but how does the Spirit relate specifically to the royal/Davidic Messiah (and, thus, to Jesus’ identification with this figure)? The association goes back to an ancient Near Eastern concept of charismatic kingship, whereby the king was seen to be specially favored and gifted by the gods, so as to be equipped and able to rule effectively. We see vestiges of this traditional conception in some of the earlier narrative strata of the Scriptures. It is expressed according to two primary aspects, whereby the manifest Spirit of God results in: (1) wisdom, insight, and skill for ruling; and (2) military leadership and prowess in battle.
With regard to the former, Joshua is perhaps the principal example, though the references are quite limited (Num 27:18; Deut 34:9). Like Elisha who followed Elijah (cf. above), the presence of the Spirit on/in Joshua is a continuation of the Spirit’s presence on/in Moses, enabling him to rule over God’s people (Num 11:17ff; Deut 34:10). Joseph (Gen 41:38) and Daniel (Dan 4:8-9, etc) also achieved a certain royal/ruling status, due to the presence of God’s Spirit enabling and guiding them. As for the military aspect, this is emphasized mainly in the narratives of the Judges—cf. the references regarding Othniel (3:10), Gideon (6:34), Jephthah (11:29), and Samson (13:25; 14:6, 19; 15:14).
Most relevant to the specific figure-type of the Davidic royal Messiah are the references to the Spirit in the David narratives of 1 Samuel. Particularly notable is the contrast between Saul and David. As king (the first king of Israel), God’s Spirit had come upon Saul (1 Sam 10:6, 10; 11:6), in a highly dramatic and powerful manner (note the prophetic emphasis [cf. also 19:20, 23ff]). However, following Saul’s disobedience (see chap. 15), the promise of kingship was taken away from him, to be given over to another (David), cf. 16:1-12. As part of this transfer, God’s Spirit came upon David (16:13), while, at the same time, departing from Saul, to be replaced by an evil spirit (v. 14). Especially to be noted, in relation to the Messianic figure-type, is the close connection between the anointing of David as king (v. 12) and the coming of the Spirit upon him (v. 13). The presence of God’s Spirit is mentioned elsewhere in the Scriptures, where again the emphasis is on David’s role as an inspired prophet (2 Sam 23:2; cf. also Psalm 51:11; Mk 12:36 par; Acts 1:16; 4:25).
In point of fact, the ruling and prophetic aspects of the Spirit’s presence upon chosen individuals are often blended together in the Scriptural tradition; beyond Saul and David, the examples of Moses, Joseph, and Daniel have already been noted (cf. above). This tendency allowed for the same combination to be applied readily with regard to the Messianic identity of Jesus—viz., as both King and Prophet. The Baptism scene would seem to establish both of these points of identification, even though, in the Synoptic narrative, Jesus’ identity as the royal/Davidic Messiah does not come clearly into view until the Jerusalem period.
In the next two studies (2 and 3), we will continue with our discussion of the role of the Spirit in the Baptism of Jesus. The significance of the Spirit’s role will be examined in a bit more detail; in addition, we will explore the development of the Baptism tradition in the Gospel of John, as well as give consideration to how the Spirit’s role, established in the Baptism scene, was to be demonstrated throughout Jesus’ ministry—as described in the Synoptic narrative (and, particularly, the Lukan narrative).